Home /
PRECOG / Periodic motion analysis

How PRECOG analyses periodic motion waveforms

Machines such as railway point machines move in cycles. PRECOG analyses every moment of the measured curve, so faults show up even where a single threshold would not see them.

Telemetry data process

One additional step for periodic motion

It helps to read this article once you are familiar with how PRECOG is used for continuous-operation machines (see data evaluation). Only one additional step is needed when the same approach is used for periodic motion: PRECOG has to be calculated for each moment in time along the curve.

For this, select a single moment and gather the values of that moment from every curve, as shown in the figure. When the calculation is done for every moment, it gives a clear picture of which segments of the curve contain anomalies.

Left: power curves of ten motions over time in milliseconds, with the power values of one selected moment marked on every curve. Right: the power values of the ten motions at that moment, motion by motion
The picture shows the power values of each motion over time, in milliseconds.

Each moment of a periodic curve is evaluated, so one motion can show several anomalies at once. Counting them gives a good picture of the general health of the machine.

Target and tolerance

Setting the first target values

In our experience it is worth setting the target value for each moment to the maximum value recorded during proper operation under normal operating conditions, and basing the tolerance on the standard deviation of the data. The specifications of the manufacturer, such as the maximum power consumption, must be taken into account as well. After that, test cases can refine the target and tolerance values until the wanted result is reached.

Measurement

The measuring instrument matters

The accuracy, the sensitivity and the sampling frequency of the measuring instrument can strongly influence which fault types can be detected in a device. Review the technical specification of the instrument carefully and test it on a sample device before a wide roll-out.

Example. For three-phase AC motors, the type of low-pass filter in the instrument is an important point, because it decides how much the measured power curve is smoothed.

Recipes

Dividing the curve into sections with recipes

For a more refined analysis, and to tell the possible faults apart, the curve is divided into smaller sections based on the test results. The analysis of the test data shows which time periods have to be monitored.

A recipe can then be written for quick and easy evaluation of the data that PRECOG provides. The recipe can be fine-tuned from experience and, in most cases, can be applied right away to many units of the same type of equipment. Each section is evaluated against the recipe to identify the fault.

Example 1

Stress due to a deformed switch blade

A power curve over the swing time in milliseconds, divided into ten numbered sections, with coloured bars that mark the detected anomalies in sections 4 to 8
The chart shows the power curve over the swing time in milliseconds. Coloured bars mark the detected anomalies.

The recipe

Section Relevant Percentage Number of anomalies / range of motion
1 to 3 Yes above 90% Low / inside
4 Yes above 30% Multiple / inside
5 Yes above 80% Few / inside
6 Yes above 30% Irrelevant / below
7 Yes above 15% Irrelevant / below
8 Yes above 60% Irrelevant / below
9 Yes above 50% Low / inside
10 Yes above 90% Low / inside

Example 2

Abnormal operation due to extraneous material

A power curve over the swing time in milliseconds with red bars that mark the detected anomalies in sections 8 and 10
The chart shows the power curve over the swing time in milliseconds. Coloured bars mark the detected anomalies.

PRECOG also finds the faults that threshold methods find, so one approach covers every fault that the measured data can show.

The recipe

Section Relevant Percentage Number of anomalies / range of motion
1 to 7 No
8 Yes above 70% Multiple / above
9 No
10 Yes above 85% Multiple / above

The same recipe approach works for other periodic machines, for example the railway turnouts in the railway case study.